Thanks for all the kudos about our foods! It is not uncommon for it to take 2-3 feedings for the fish to get used to a new food in our experience.
We take great pains to strain and press our foods to remove any excess water so I don't know why it would seem "watered down."
I recently uploaded this video of our Herbivore Frenzy just after loading the packing machine. As the video depicts the blend is very thick, almost like dry oatmeal and not of a "soupy" consistency like some other mass produced blends. I think it shows the consistency pretty accurately.
Thanks all!
Larry
