To be quite honest, I think you could go with neither one and be just fine too. Don't get me wrong, I have a DSB in my new tank and had one before as well. I truly think these systems actually come in place to play a bigger role in larger systems that are very heavily loaded with fish AND corals with inefficient skimming. That is just my biased view though. On the other hand, it does offer some level of buffering when things start to go down hill.